Re: More Icon Revisions for 1.4…

[Jordan]

I like the idea of using Adiumy, but it seems like it would steer the
icon further from the intended meaning. This is likely why Peter
prefers the OS X Guy icon over the rest, as it is most likely to
convey the meaning accurately of the 5. Additionally, I agree with
Peter that none of them hit the mark dead on and I think this is
because none of them immediately make me think that the icon
represents "Mention."

That said, the icon will not be alone in representing the meaning -
the meaning is written directly beside it in the advanced prefpane, so
the icon's accuracy to its intended meaning is not a necessity. As a
result of this, I think the Adiumy head is my favourite of the bunch
due to it being the easiest to recognize between the two Adiumy-themed
icons.

I'm curious as to what others involved with the project find to be
their favourites!

Jordan



On Thu, Jun 3, 2010 at 12:07 AM, Peter Hosey <boredzo at adium.im> wrote:
> On Jun 2, 2010, at 20:05:04, George Lambrou wrote:
>> <Mention (OS X Guy).png>
>
> I think this one comes closest, although none of the quintet hit the mark dead-on for me.
>
>
>